20 years on, there's been no better adaptation of DC's Justice League than Bruce Timm's TV show
May. 29, 2024Opinion | Animated series Justice League is undoubtedly the best adaptation of DC’s super-team
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
Across 52 episodes, Justice League expanded the world Bruce Timm and co. created in those first two shows with the best adaptation of DC’s premier super-team to date. And yes, that absolutely includes anything and everythingZack Snydergot his hands on, as well as the fan-favorite Young Justice series and popular animated films like Doom and The New Frontier.
Found family
That’s not to say Justice League soared from the get-go. The initial three-part alien invasion that first brought The Seven together falls a bit flat now in hindsight, but from that point on, the show successfully juggled each giant personality with natural ease, which is no easy feat given that they’re not designed to mesh together in the same way that a family like Marvel’s Fantastic Four or X-Men do. Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern, Martian Manhunter, Hawkgirl, and Flash were all created separately, yet you wouldn’t know that when watching Timm’s Justice League.
Whether the story at hand brought in the whole cast or featured just a select few heroes at a time, everyone had their fair share of the spotlight with unique character dynamics that made the team feel like a family and not just randoms brought together to fight a threat too big for any one hero. There’s too many to name here, but highlights of this include Batman’s begrudging respect for The Flash’s kid-like exuberance, Martian Manhunter singing a Martian song with the Kents at Christmas, or when the team had to decide what to do with Hawkgirl afterthatbetrayal.
These emotional beats resonated so strongly because Justice League embraced continuity across multi-part storylines and even longer season-wide plotlines that gave the characters space to connect with us and each other beyond flashy displays of power. The same can also be said for the supporting characters and one-off guest appearances, including a wider rogues' gallery far removed from the usual Batman villains that DC likes to peddle out. Each was given equal respect by the creators who clearly held a deep love for the source material, and the same is true of the voice talent who brought them to life as well.
AlongsideKevin Conroy, the definitive Batman for many, Justice League’s pitch-perfect voice actors also included Smallville’s Michael Rosenbaum and Supergirl’s Carl Lumbly, as the Flash and Martian Manhunter respectively. Together, the cast balanced all the stoic heroics we’ve come to expect from these heroes with a lighter touch that no other adaptation has nailed so easily, before and since. Because yes, the world needs saving and sure, there’s a lot at stake, but that doesn’t mean everyone has to scowl under their cowl the whole time. Even more serious characters like Green Lantern and Hawkgirl enjoyed occasional lighthearted moments in the show, reminding us that they’re ultimately still human whether they were born in the US or on Thanagar.
Subsequent adaptations like The CW’sArrowverseor Snyder’s Snyderverse attempted that same balance, but often skewed much further in one direction over the other, often to mixed results. After all, it’s hard to enjoy banter when Supes is snapping necks or Aquaman is bro’ing out to the Nth degree.
Bringing all the latest movie news, features, and reviews to your inbox
Like Marvel’s animated X-Men series from a decade earlier, Justice League had universal appeal in that sense, treating both audiences and the team itself with the kind of respect live-action cinema wouldn’t even begin to attempt until a few years later.
This was also reflected in Timm’s signature animation style which channeled the grandeur of classic Golden Age and Silver Age comics with much-needed weight in the fight scenes, imbuing them with a tangible physicality sans blood or gore. When Superman hits Darkseid and lets out all his pent-up frustration in one earth-shattering punch, you viscerally feel the rage the Kryptonian boy scout is barely able to contain. That terribly dated CGI opening aside, it’s remarkable how well all this animation stands up still today.
With this in mind, it’s baffling how theZack Snyderfilms in particular just cast aside this timeless, proven blueprint in favor of what they came up with over at Warner Bros. That’s not to say new creators shouldn’t try new things — that’s exactly how the DC mythos has thrived so long in the comics — but there’s so much to gain from studying Timm’s Justice League cartoon specifically, not least how the show prioritized lesser known versions of iconic heroes like Hawkgirl over Hawkman, Wally West over Barry Allen, and John Stewart over Hal Jordan, reminding us that there’s so much more scope to this universe beyond the usual go-to heavy hitters
After the season two finale, Justice League delved into this further by rebranding as Justice League Unlimited, an expansive follow-up that brought in countless more DC heroes who finally received the spotlight they had long deserved, but were so rarely given. There were stand-out moments for sure — try thinking about Batman on that swing with Ace and not crying — but at times it was very overstuffed, trying to do too much at once. Yet that hasn’t stopped fans from clamoring to see more of this version ever since.
Season 1 of Justice League is available to stream now on Netflix.
Discover what else to add to your watchlist with our guide to theupcoming superhero moviessoon heading your way.
Invincible season 3 trailer teases darkness to come thanks to Mark’s blue suit
Ryan Reynolds told James Gunn to “get the f*** out of here” when he asked the former Green Lantern star to come back for the DCU
Get hundreds of hours of RPG goodness for $30 with this bundle of 8 games that includes the first two Baldur’s Gate games, which are absolutely worth playing
