IP expert says Nintendo's Palworld lawsuit is "more likely" to take 5 years than to finish in 1, but Pocketpair can "easily" afford the legal battle
Sep. 20, 2024“This is not a simple ‘pay me a million’ patent suit”
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
One IP expert predicts thatNintendo and The Pokemon Company’s lawsuit against Palworlddeveloper Pocketpair is “more likely to last five years” than be settled in just one, but he’s also confident that the indie survival game studio can “easily” afford the battle to come.
Posting on Twitter, former Blizzard consultantFlorian Mueller claimsthat the lawsuit probably won’t have a “simple” settlement, and that it could go on for some time. “Nintendo v. [Pocketpair] looks to me like a dispute that is more likely to last five years than to be settled during the first year,” Mueller says. “In fact, it could be that Nintendo actually wants to see it through and wants it to take long. This is not a simple ‘pay me a million’ patent suit.”
Later down in the thread, Mueller says that he doesn’t expect that Pocketpair will struggle with the costs of the battle,claiming thatthe studio “can afford that. Easily.” He adds that “Pocketpair can defend,“and: “This is not like Epic v. Apple andGooglecosting hundreds of millions.”
Right now, it’s hard to know one way or another where the legal battle will end up. The lawsuit alleges that Pocketpair’s game “infringes multiple patents,” but Nintendo hasn’t publicly revealed which patents these are. Speaking to GamesRadar+, however, analyst Serkan Toto tells us that Nintendo has “a very, very strong legal team that is feared in the Japanese gaming industry,” and"looking at the track record, it’s highly likely that they win.”
For now, we’ll just have to wait and see, but if what Mueller predicts is true about the length of the battle, it could be quite some time before we know the result. Publicly responding to the news yesterday,Pocketpair said “we will do our utmost for our fans,and to ensure that indie game developers are not hindered or discouraged from pursuing their creative ideas.”
Nintendo’s Pokeball patent could be at the heart of its Palworld lawsuit, and judging by a 29-year-old precedent it could change monster-collecting RPGs for decades.
Sign up to the GamesRadar+ Newsletter
Weekly digests, tales from the communities you love, and more
I’m one of GamesRadar+’s news writers, who works alongside the rest of the news team to deliver cool gaming stories that we love. After spending more hours than I can count filling The University of Sheffield’s student newspaper with Pokemon and indie game content, and picking up a degree in Journalism Studies, I started my career at GAMINGbible where I worked as a journalist for over a year and a half. I then became TechRadar Gaming’s news writer, where I sourced stories and wrote about all sorts of intriguing topics. In my spare time, you’re sure to find me on my Nintendo Switch or PS5 playing through story-driven RPGs like Xenoblade Chronicles and Persona 5 Royal, nuzlocking old Pokemon games, or going for a Victory Royale in Fortnite.
A mysterious Palworld update appears to make a change designed to get around the survival game’s legal battle with Nintendo
Five years later, PUBG creator PlayerUnknown finally reveals his massive open-world survival game projects, aiming for “realistic worlds thousands of kilometers wide” across three games
One of the least known Marvel Rivals heroes is back in comics as Luna Snow and her team return in their own title - but this time they’re working for Doctor Doom
