I've fallen in love with Elden Ring's absolute worst area – just like I did with Dark Souls and Bloodborne

Mar. 14, 2024

Opinion | Areas I once hated in some of my favorite action RPGs are now places I relish

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.

In comparative terms, I’d place Blighttown up there with Bloodborne’s Yahar’gul, the Unseen Village and Elden Ring’s Caelid. The thing is, while all three of these started out as my least favorite, most-hated locations to visit in their respective overarching settings, I have, one-by-one, fallen in love with each place – so much so, and I cannot believe I’m saying this, they might actually be my favorites.

Bright town

After almost 400 hours with Elden Ring, I’ve found the action RPG’s hardest enemy – an innocuous, random teleporting knight who you might have missed entirely

Can I even explain myself? I know Ishould, but I’m not entirely sure Ican. Okay, so Blighttown, Yahar’gul and Caelid are now among my favorite-ever video game settings – how did this happen? I’m no game developer, but I think my steadily growing fondness for what are essentially brutal, gross and inherently unforgiving nightmare-scapes is down to what each one represents. These horrid slices of hell epitomize the FromSoftware experience, each filled with enemies a few levels above your limit; each lined with environmental hazards that’ll scorch the ‘You Died’ killscreen into your brain. These areas are designed to be bastard hard, they’re designed to repel you, and yet it’s these very traits that draw you back in.

As action role-playing games, a key facet of progression in Dark Souls, Bloodborne and Elden Ring is leveling up your character. These games' open-ended maps and teleportation mechanics often mean once you’ve left these areas behind, you no longer need to return – however, doing so several levels stronger down the line, while packing overpowered weapons, armor and magic can be a liberating experience. That giant who gave you hell when you were a lowly level 16 with pithy Strength and Dexterity armed with an Astora Straight Sword? See how he feels about being smacked upside the head with a +15 Lightning Halberd when you’re pushing level 100. Elder Dragon Greyoll kicked your arse a couple of dozen hours ago? Get your own back with a blast of Comet Azur followed by a shower of Glintstone Comets.

“And so when you remove the challenge and, by extension, the terror in these otherwise ghastly locales, you’re free to take in their beauty.”

And so when you remove the challenge and, by extension, the terror in these otherwise ghastly locales, you’re free to take in their beauty. Blighttown is amassivespace that acts as a crossroads to some key Dark Souls areas – not least The Depths above, Firelink Shrine and New Londo Ruins at the far end, Valley of the Drakes adjacent, and Quaalag’s Domain and Demon Ruins below. The same can be said for Bloodborne’s Yahar’gul, the Unseen Village, with its high-level jailers, crumbling white stone masonry, and gateways to Cathedral Ward, the Nightmare of Mensis and the One Reborn. As for Caelid, taking in its glowing purple skies, rivers of blood, and Scarlet Rot-ridden plains on horseback is my new favorite thing to do in Elden Ring, sauntering between the Bestial Sanctum and Redmaine Castle atop Torent. It’s an awful place with a Doomsday vibe, and yet… it’s perfect.

I’ve become a wee bit obsessed with the lore tied to Elden Ring’s Scarlet Rot, how it bounds Malenia and Miquella, which is even more pertinent now given the confirmed direction of its incomingShadow of the Erdtree DLC. We’ll access the first slice of added content via Mohgwyn Palace, assuming we’ve already defeated Mohg, Lord of Blood. Without Caelid, though, there is no Mohgwyn Palace, making it arguably the most important game location besides the Erdtree itself.

All of which is full credit to FromSoftware’s processes. To have the skill and ability to craft locations that start off as the absolute worst thing imaginable, but eventually grow into favorites is an achievement in itself. Caelid, Yahar’gul and Blighttown, I love ‘em all. And withtalk of Shadow of the Erdtree including poisonous swaps, I can’t wait to see where my next love-to-hate and hate-to-love location falls next.

Weekly digests, tales from the communities you love, and more

OurElden Ring reviewreckons “suffering has never been so much fun”

Diablo 4 DLC director is “sticking to my guns” on the dungeon you can’t enter unless you have friends

After 48 hours and 729 deaths, Elden Ring sicko takes on the RPG’s hardest challenge so far by beating the base game and DLC on NG+ 1,000 without getting hit once

A year after pitching the idea to DC, Mike Flanagan is officially writing a Clayface movie