Nintendo accidentally created one of the best-selling PS1 games by saying no to a 3D Yoshi platformer that Miyamoto "loved," and after 27 years it's getting remastered
Aug. 30, 2024“We showed it to Miyamoto-san and he was blown away”
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
27 years after its original launch, Croc: Legend of the Gobbos is getting a remaster courtesy of Argonaut Games, which has reformed after 20 years dead. Croc was a massive hit back on the PS1, but it could’ve taken a very different form if the original pitch for the game as a 3D Yoshi platformer had not been rejected by Nintendo.
A new version of Croc: Legend of the Gobbos was announced earlier this week, and judging by the teaser trailer it looks to be a faithful remaster of the original PS1 platformer. The devs have not provided any details on what platforms the game is coming to or what new features it’ll include, but onsocial mediathey say “we’re aiming for a release later this year!”
There’s some continuity with the original studio, too, as co-CEO Gary Sheinwald “I worked closely with Jez on the design and production of Starglider, Argonaut’s first big hit back in 1986, so to take up the mantle of relaunching Argonaut Games nearly four decades later brings me full circle, and we have further exciting announcements in the pipeline in the coming months.”
‘Jez’ refers to original studio founder Jez San, who’s been hyping up this project forover a year, and hastold the story of Croc’s origins a few times. In every telling, it seems that even Shigeru Miyamoto himself “loved it.”
San elaborated on the story in issue 154 of Retro Gamer magazine: “We offered them what we called Yoshi Racing, which was a 3D Mario game with the Yoshi character. It was probably a cross between Mario Kart and Super Mario World, a hybrid of a racing game and a platformer. It also looked like Super Mario 64, only a year or two earlier.”
San said, “We showed it to Miyamoto-san and he was blown away. “It was clear we were on to something - this was special. It was at that point that they kind of said, ‘No, we’re not doing it.'” Nintendo didn’t provide a clear reason why the pitch was rejected - at least, not that San revealed - but the devs started reworking their prototype, transforming Yoshi into an original character they could use in their own game.
Sign up to the GamesRadar+ Newsletter
Weekly digests, tales from the communities you love, and more
The result was Croc, which launched in 1997 to decent reviews and fantastic sales -reportedback in the day as over 3 million units. That makes it one of the best-selling games in the PS1’s massive library, ifWikipedia’s aggregation on sales data is to be believed, ahead of the likes of Dino Crisis, Final Fantasy Tactics, and Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 3.
In the time between Argonaut’s initial pitch for Yoshi Racing and Croc’s eventual release, 3D platformers had their breakout moment with the launch of Super Mario 64. “Little did we know that Nintendo had effectively run with our idea and produced a game that was very similar,” San told Retro Gamer. “Mario 64 was very similar in concept to what we had shown Miyamoto a year or two earlier. And Miyamoto actually came up to me at the launch at the CES show and apologised for not doing Yoshi Racing with us and then doing Mario 64 instead. He said, ‘You’ll make enough money. You’ve made enough money from Star Fox and Stunt Race. You’re not going to worry.’ It was a bit hollow.” Still, San reckoned, “Miyamoto is the best guy in the industry.”
We shall know no rest until all of thebest PS1 gamesare remastered.
Antonblast review: “Explosively reinvents the destructive energy of Wario Land”
The joyous momentum of 16-bit Sonic is finally recaptured in 3D thanks to Penny’s Big Breakaway, once you learn its fantastic and unique controls
Dev behind new Doki Doki Literature Club-style psychological horror says it’s not “for those with weak hearts,” but with 98% positive Steam reviews, I’m not sure I can stay away
