StarCraft is coming to Game Pass and there are rumors of a shooter spin-off, but a true StarCraft 3 RTS will stay a pipe dream if the series can't adapt

Oct. 7, 2024

Opinion | The strategy genre has changed, and StarCraft risks falling behind

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.

I have fond (if painful memories) of trying to master all three of StarCraft 2’s factions at once, throwing myself into the zerg’s trial-by-fire horde playstyle and, once that felt too hard, dropping it to learn Protos' quality over quantity tactics. I never quite clicked with either – it was the safe, reliable Terrans I did best with – but it was the first and only time I’ve been so driven to compete in a strategy game.

Even 14 years later, I’m yet to find another RTS that has grabbed me in the same ways StarCraft did. So when it wasrecently reported that a StarCraft shooter was in the works, my immediate reaction was two-fold: as much as I crave a new story in Blizzard’s sci-fi world, I’dmuchrather be looking at that world from a top-down perspective. But given how much has changed since StarCraft 2 launched, I have to wonder what something like StarCraft 3 would even look like.

Construct additional pylons

Keep your tactics sharp by playing thebest strategy games

Meanwhile, I can count on one hand the amount of recent studios trying to capture that traditional formula. The big one is Stormgate developer Frost Giant Studios – while ourStormgate reviewflagged room for improvement, the game is currently in Early Access, and its first major update in September has been well-received by fans. On one hand, it shows there’s an appetite for this style of RTS – but even Frost Giant Studios CEO Tim Morten, who was the production director for StarCraft 2, feels Blizzard would have to think big for StarCraft 3.

“I would hope to see StarCraft 3 try something radically new to advance the genre, like being an open world or introducing game modes that are radically different for accessibility with a greater ability to game with friends,” Morten tells GamesRadar+. Though I can’t picture an open-world StarCraft game myself, I completely agree with Morten’s point – it’s hard to imagine a safe follow-up succeeding in today’s landscape.

Weekly digests, tales from the communities you love, and more

For all of its strengths, StarCraft could never quite connect with a casual audience, as a lack of onboarding meant that players could only learn how to play throughYouTubetutorials and one crushing defeat after another. This is something that developers have become much better at in recent years. Last year’s Warhammer Age of Sigmar: Realms of Ruin, which sticks to that classic RTS formula, did this quite well, as streamlined unit production and less intensive micro-management meant that you could focus more on tougher concepts and the broader strategy of each match. Even grand strategies Crusader Kings 3 and Stellaris have made it to console, which defies the assumption that the genre’s toughest games are restricted to nicher PC audiences.

If by some miracle Blizzard decided to greenlight StarCraft 3 – and by all accounts,the studio is dying to get back to its strategic ways– opening the series up to more players feels crucial. Besides the innovation that Morten points to, there’s certainly room for StarCraft’s larger-than-life campaigns to make a comeback, as very little can match a level propped up by one of the studio’sjaw-dropping cinematics. Ultimately, maybe the easiest way to bring back StarCraft reallyisthrough a shooter, even if past attempts at doing sohaven’t worked out. Perhaps the times have indeed changed, and there really aren’t as many wrist-cramped fans clamoring for a true follow-up. But as someone who’s spent far too long gleefully mismanaging legions of doomed Zerg, Protoss and Terrans, it would be a shame to see Blizzard call it quits on the strategy genre rather than adapt to what it’s become.

Don’t let your APM get rusty - check out thebest PC gamesyou can play right now.

Warcraft 2 just got its “first balance changes in 24 years,” including a nerf RTS players have wanted since 1995

Dev behind new Doki Doki Literature Club-style psychological horror says it’s not “for those with weak hearts,” but with 98% positive Steam reviews, I’m not sure I can stay away