Wish review: "Disney's 100th anniversary fairy tale sure is pretty but lacks heart"
Nov. 17, 2023Ravishingly pretty but low-powered, this cute and earnest fairy tale has a whole lot of homage, but not enough heart.
Why you can trust GamesRadar+Our experts review games, movies and tech over countless hours, so you can choose the best for you.Find out more about our reviews policy.
Disneyhas stellar hopes for this charming but old-school family musical. A graceful homage to classic Mouse House fairy tales like Snow White and Sleeping Beauty, Wish has been released with much fanfare as part of Disney’s centenary celebrations.
Centered on a nostalgia-laden wishing ‘star’, a Disney staple since Pinocchio, it sends plucky, adorkable teen Asha (Ariana DeBose) to apprentice herself to benevolent sorcerer King Magnifico (a sly Chris Pine), who collects his happy population’s wishes, granting a lucky few their heart’s desires in thrilling, X Factor-style ceremonies.
Directors Chris Buck (Frozen) and Fawn Veerasunthorn paint the medieval kingdom of Rosas in gorgeous watercolour landscapes reminiscent of Snow White, but give Asha (the first Afro-Latina Disney heroine) a distinctly modern gutsiness. Discovering that Magnifico secretly uses the wishes to control his subjects, she enlists the cute, trouble-making Star that’s fallen to earth to help her free the people with its wild magic.
Where’s something to rival the sister-jeopardy that electrified Frozen, or the hilarious bond thatMoanaforged with Maui? Valentino, Asha’s newly talking pet goat (Alan Tudyk) is a quirky delight, but neither he nor the squeakily adorable Star (a multi-million merch opportunity in the making) have any depth. The film also needs more musical-theatre-style oomph, a fewEncanto-type bangers to enliven its forgettable soundtrack. DeBose works valiantly to put heart into the wistful ‘I-want’ song This Wish, but it’s still a verbose pop ballad that your kids won’t be singing on repeat.
For the first time in forever, though, Disney has a proper villain. Chris Pine gives Magnifico’s transformation into aMaleficent-esque monster his best shot, gleefully whipping fluo-green ‘Forbidden Magic’ around his subjects in a storm of power-crazed narcissism. In a movie that’s beautifully animated and nicely played, and full of child-friendly lessons about mistaking social control for protection, he’s the big ball of malevolent energy who proves that bad guys have more fun.
Wish is released in US cinemas on November 22 and in UK cinemas on November 24.
Check out our list of thebest Disney moviesyou can watch now.
More info
Kate is a freelance film journalist and critic. Her bylines have appeared online and in print for GamesRadar, Total Film, the BFI, Sight & Sounds, and WithGuitars.com.
“It seems we’ve missed the mark”: As their Steam review score drops to 14%, Dauntless devs wade into feedback after a disastrous update that gutted progress
Netflix’s new #1 movie is a sci-fi thriller that stars Megan Fox as an AI robot - and it has a pretty divisive Rotten Tomatoes score
“It’s impossible to not be cocky when you have a game like this”: It Takes Two’s Josef Fares is back and drumming up another Game Awards reveal
